Turtle
Graham crust, vanilla custard, hot fudge, caramel, pecans, cherries
Custard Pies
Frozen custard pies for birthdays, holidays, and any day that needs a pie.
Please tell us about any allergies when you order.
Year-round pies
Made with our fresh frozen custard. Order ahead: we need a day to make your pie, so pickup starts two days after you order. Some pies may be in stock but cannot be guaranteed.
Your way
Create your own pie
Up to 3 toppings. Custom pies are priced by the toppings you pick, and we'll contact you to confirm after you order.. Order ahead: we need a day to make your pie, so pickup starts two days after you order. Some pies may be in stock but cannot be guaranteed.
Strawberry Fudge Truffle
Graham crust, vanilla custard, hot fudge, strawberries
Raspberry Fudge Truffle
Graham crust, vanilla custard, hot fudge, raspberries
Hot Fudge Oreo
Chocolate graham crust, vanilla custard, hot fudge, Oreos, cherries
Holiday pies
Seasonal pies follow each holiday window's own order-due date.
Holiday
Pumpkin
Graham crust, pumpkin custard, cinnamon sprinkles
Holiday
Pumpkin Caramel Pecan
Graham crust, pumpkin custard, caramel, pecans, cherries
Holiday
Cinnamon
Graham crust, cinnamon custard, cinnamon sprinkles
Holiday
Maple Pecan
Graham crust, maple custard, caramel, pecans, cherries
Holiday
Irish Cream
Chocolate graham crust, Irish cream custard, hot fudge, chocolate cake crumbles
Holiday
Peppermint
Chocolate graham crust, peppermint custard, peppermint pieces
Holiday
Hot Fudge Oreo Peppermint
Chocolate graham crust, peppermint custard, hot fudge, Oreos, peppermint pieces
Holiday
Black Forest
Chocolate graham crust, vanilla custard, hot fudge, old fashioned cherries
Holiday
Peanut Butter Overload
Graham crust, peanut butter custard, Reese's PB cups, Reese's PB sauce
Holiday
Taffy Apple
Graham crust, vanilla custard, apple topping, caramel, chopped nuts, cherries
Holiday
Strawberry Banana
Graham crust, vanilla custard, strawberries, bananas
Holiday
Marshmallow Peep
Graham crust, marshmallow custard, Cadbury Mini Eggs, Peeps
Holiday
S'More
Graham crust, marshmallow custard, hot fudge, Easter marshmallows, cherry
Holiday
Samoa
Graham crust, vanilla custard, caramel, hardening chocolate, coconut, cherry
Prices and flavors are subject to change without notice.