Custard pies

Regular pies

Made with our fresh frozen custard. Order ahead: we need a day to make your pie, so pickup starts two days after you order. Some pies may be in stock but cannot be guaranteed.

• TurtleGraham crust, vanilla custard, hot fudge, caramel, pecans, cherries
• Strawberry Fudge TruffleGraham crust, vanilla custard, hot fudge, strawberries
• Raspberry Fudge TruffleGraham crust, vanilla custard, hot fudge, raspberries
• Hot Fudge OreoChocolate graham crust, vanilla custard, hot fudge, Oreos, cherries
• Create Your OwnUp to 3 toppings. Custom pies are priced by the toppings you pick, and we'll contact you to confirm after you order.

Don't see the pie you want? Email info@olliesfrozencustard.com or call (815) 758-8222 during open hours.

Holiday pies

Seasonal pies follow each holiday window's own order-due date: order forms open, orders due, then pickup at the window.

• PumpkinGraham crust, pumpkin custard, cinnamon sprinkles
• Pumpkin Caramel PecanGraham crust, pumpkin custard, caramel, pecans, cherries
• CinnamonGraham crust, cinnamon custard, cinnamon sprinkles
• Maple PecanGraham crust, maple custard, caramel, pecans, cherries
• Irish CreamChocolate graham crust, Irish cream custard, hot fudge, chocolate cake crumbles
• PeppermintChocolate graham crust, peppermint custard, peppermint pieces
• Hot Fudge Oreo PeppermintChocolate graham crust, peppermint custard, hot fudge, Oreos, peppermint pieces
• Black ForestChocolate graham crust, vanilla custard, hot fudge, old fashioned cherries
• Peanut Butter OverloadGraham crust, peanut butter custard, Reese's PB cups, Reese's PB sauce
• Taffy AppleGraham crust, vanilla custard, apple topping, caramel, chopped nuts, cherries
• Strawberry BananaGraham crust, vanilla custard, strawberries, bananas
• Marshmallow PeepGraham crust, marshmallow custard, Cadbury Mini Eggs, Peeps
• S'MoreGraham crust, marshmallow custard, hot fudge, Easter marshmallows, cherry
• SamoaGraham crust, vanilla custard, caramel, hardening chocolate, coconut, cherry